田高龙,徐流杰,李洲,张连杰

• 1:河南科技大学材料科学与工程学院
• 2:河南科技大学金属材料磨损控制与成型技术国家地方联合工程研究中心

摘要(Abstract)：

TZM合金具有熔点高、强度大、线膨胀系数小、耐蚀性强以及高温力学性能良好等特点，是应用最为广泛的钼合金之一，在许多领域具有不可替代的作用。本文从TZM合金的研究现状出发，在钼合金热加工成型与强化理论基础上，综述了TZM合金的制备方法、力学性能的调控方法、显微组织的调控以及研究的最新进展。介绍了调控策略，如改变掺杂和烧结工艺，合金元素和第二相调控。此外，还讨论了这些界面与TZM合金性能之间的关系。最后，结合强韧化机理对TZM合金的未来研究方向与开发进行了展望。

关键词(KeyWords)： TZM合金;显微组织;力学性能;调控方法

Abstract:

Keywords:

基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金(U1804124);; 国家重点研发计划(2020YFB2008400)

作者(Author): 田高龙,徐流杰,李洲,张连杰

DOI: 10.13289/j.issn.1009-6264.2023-0078

参考文献(References)：

• [1] Xia Y,Hu P,Wang K S,et al.Microstructure and texture evolution of pure molybdenum during hot deformation[J].Materials Characterization,2020,159:110010.
• [2] Meng B,Wan M,Wu X,et al.Constitutive modeling for high-temperature tensile deformation behavior of pure molybdenum considering strain effects[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2014,45:41-47.
• [3] Kaserer L,Braun J,Stajkovic J,et al.Fully dense and crack free molybdenum manufactured by selective laser melting through alloying with carbon[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2019,84:105000.
• [4] Cho G S,Ahn G B,Choe K H.Creep microstructures and creep behaviors of pure molybdenum sheet at 0.7 Tm[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2016,60:52-57.
• [5] Harimon M A,Hidayati N A,Miyashita Y,et al.High temperature fracture toughness of TZM alloys with different kinds of grain boundary particles[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2017,66:52-56.
• [6] 陈艳芳，谢敬佩，苌清华，等.钼粉制备技术的研究进展[J].材料热处理学报，2020,41(7):14-24.CHEN Yan-fang,XIE Jing-pei,CHANG Qing-hua,et al.Research progress in preparation technology of molybdenum powder[J].Transactions of Materials and Heat Treatment,2020,41(7):14-24.
• [7] 胡亚杰，徐流杰，周玉成，等.水热法制备Al2O3掺杂钼合金[J].材料热处理学报，2015,36(6):15-20.HU Ya-jie,XU Liu-jie,ZHOU Yu-cheng,et al.Preparation of molybdenum alloy doped with Al2O3 by hydrothermal synthesis method[J].Transactions of Materials and Heat Treatment,2015,36(6):15-20.
• [8] 符明君，张勇，张耿飞，等.钼及钼合金改性硅化物高温抗氧化涂层研究现状[J].材料导报，2023,37(3):177-184.FU Ming-jun,ZHANG Yong,ZHANG Geng-fei,et al.Research progress of high temperature antioxidant modified silicide coatings of molybdenum and its alloys[J].Materials Reports,2023,37(3):177-184.
• [9] Lenchuk O,Rohrer J,Albe K.Cohesive strength of zirconia/molybdenum interfaces and grain boundaries in molybdenum:A comparative study[J].Acta Materialia,2017,135:150-157.
• [10] Wei Y,Luo L M,Zan X,et al.Microstructural evolution and mechanical properties of carbon nanotubes-reinforced TZM composites synthesized by powder metallurgy[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2020,829:154540.
• [11] Ki Yoo M,Hiraoka Y,Kurishita H,et al.Recrystallization of TiC dispersion Mo-alloy[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,1996,14(5):355-364.
• [12] Majumdar S,Kapoor R,Raveendra S,et al.A study of hot deformation behavior and microstructural characterization of Mo-TZM alloy[J].Journal of Nuclear Materials,2009,385(3):545-551.
• [13] Majumdar S.Formation of MoSi2 and al doped MoSi2 coatings on molybdenum base TZM (Mo-0.5Ti-0.1Zr-0.02C) alloy[J].Surface and Coatings Technology,2012,206(15):3393-3398.
• [14] Ahmadi E,Malekzadeh M,Sadrnezhaad S K.Preparation of nanostructured high-temperature TZM alloy by mechanical alloying and sintering[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2011,29(1):141-145.
• [15] Sirali H,Simsek D,Ozyurek D.Investigation of the effect of zirconium amount on grain size and wear performance in TZM alloys produced by mechanical alloying method[J].Transactions of the Indian Institute of Metals,2022,75(3):805-812.
• [16] Gu L,Zhu Y,Zhang F,et al.Mechanism analysation and parameter optimisation of electro discharge machining of titanium-zirconium-molybdenum alloy[J].Journal of Manufacturing Processes,2018,32:773-781.
• [17] Browning P N,Fignar J,Kulkarni A,et al.Sintering behavior and mechanical properties of Mo-TZM alloyed with nanotitanium carbide[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2017,62:78-84.
• [18] 朱向炜，张国赏，魏世忠，等.Ti、Zr加入形式对TZM合金组织和性能的影响[J].稀有金属与硬质合金，2013,41(4):30-33.ZHU Xiang-wei,ZHANG Guo-shang,WEI Shi-zhong,et al.Effect of Ti and Zr adding forms on microstructure and properties of TZM alloy[J].Rare Metals and Cemented Carbides,2013,41(4):30-33.
• [19] Majumdar S,Sharma I G,Samajdar I,et al.Preparation of Mo-Ti-Zr-C alloy tube by p/m route[J].Nuclear Engineering and Design,2010,240(5):975-979.
• [20] Hu P,Chang T,Yu Z T,et al.Synthesis of hypoxia-high density TZM alloy based on mechanochemistry and particle size distribution theories[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2017,698:994-1001.
• [21] Majumdar S,Raveendra S,Samajdar I,et al.Densification and grain growth during isothermal sintering of mo and mechanically alloyed Mo-TZM[J].Acta Materialia,2009,57(14):4158-4168.
• [22] Suryanarayana C,Ivanov E,Boldyrev V V.The science and technology of mechanical alloying[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2001,304:151-158.
• [23] Zhang L,Li X Y,Qu X H,et al.Powder metallurgy route to ultrafine-grained refractory metals[J].Advanced Materials,2022:2205807.
• [24] Calderon H A,Kostorz G,Ullrich G.Microstructure and plasticity of two molybdenum-base alloys (TZM)[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,1993,160(2):189-199.
• [25] Cockeram B V.The fracture toughness and toughening mechanism of commercially available unalloyed molybdenum and oxide dispersion strengthened molybdenum with an equiaxed,large grain structure[J].Metallurgical and Materials Transactions A,2009,40(12):2843-2860.
• [26] Meyers M A,Mishra A,Benson D J.Mechanical properties of nanocrystalline materials[J].Progress in Materials Science,2006,51(4):427-556.
• [27] 阚金锋，王广达，郭雪琪，等.退火温度对TZM板再结晶行为和力学性能的影响[J].中国钼业，2021,45(6):51-54.KAN Jin-feng,WANG Guang-da,GUO Xue-qi,et al.Effect of annealing temperature on recrystallization behavior and mechanical properties of TZM plate[J].China Molybdenum Industry,2021,45(6):51-54.
• [28] Cockeram B V.The role of stress state on the fracture toughness and toughening mechanisms of wrought molybdenum and molybdenum alloys[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2010,528(1):288-308.
• [29] Wang L,Sun J,Liu G,et al.Influences of annealing temperature on microstructure and mechanical properties of Mo-La2O3[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2011,29(4):522-527.
• [30] Zhou H,Zhang Y,Hua X,et al.Al2O3/Mo composite and its tribological behavior against AISI201 stainless steel at elevated temperatures[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2014,43:263-268.
• [31] Chen X,Li B,Wang T,et al.Strengthening mechanisms of Mo-La2O3 alloys processed by solid-solid doping and vacuum hot-pressing sintering[J].Vacuum,2018,152:70-77.
• [32] Yang J J,Chen G,Chen Z,et al.Effects of doping route on microstructure and mechanical properties of W-1.0wt.%La2O3 alloys[J].Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China,2020,30(12):3296-3306.
• [33] Sun G D,Zhang G H,Chou K C.Nanostructured oxide dispersion strengthened Mo alloys from Mo nanopowder doping with oxide nanoparticles[J].Journal of Materials Research and Technology,2019,8(6):5753-5762.
• [34] Yang X,Tan H,Lin N,et al.The influences of La doping method on the microstructure and mechanical properties of Mo alloys[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2015,51:301-308.
• [35] Mrotzek T,Hoffmann A,Martin U.Hardening mechanisms and recrystallization behaviour of several molybdenum alloys[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2006,24(4):298-305.
• [36] 王华，张云鹏，陈兴友.Ti-Zr-Mo合金累积复合轧制工艺[J].材料热处理学报，2013,34(7):124-128.WANG Hua,ZHANG Yun-peng,CHEN Xing-you.Accumulative roll bonding process of Ti-Zr-Mo alloy[J].Transactions of Materials and Heat Treatment,2013,34(7):124-128.
• [37] Liu G,Zhang G J,Jiang F,et al.Nanostructured high-strength molybdenum alloys with unprecedented tensile ductility[J].Nature Materials,2013,12(4):344-350.
• [38] Hu P,Hu B L,Wang K S,et al.Strengthening and elongation mechanism of lanthanum-doped titanium-zirconium-molybdenum alloy[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2016,678:315-319.
• [39] Liang J,Xi Z P,Tang H P,et al.Mechanism analysis of carbide formation in TZM alloy[J].Rare Metal Materials and Engineering,2011,40:210-214.
• [40] Fang Z Z,Wang H,Kumar V.Coarsening,densification,and grain growth during sintering of nano-sized powders—a perspective[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2017,62:110-117.
• [41] Olevsky E A.Theory of sintering:From discrete to continuum[J].Materials Science and Engineering:R:Reports,1998,23(2):41-100.
• [42] 潘以庆，田青超，徐文进.钼合金顶头制备技术研究进展[J].粉末冶金技术，2021,39(5):452-461.PAN Yi-qing,TIAN Qing-chao,XU Wen-jin.Research progress on the preparation technology of molybdenum alloy piercing plug[J].Powder Metallurgy Technology,2021,39(5):452-461.
• [43] Li S L,Hu P,Han J Y,et al.The formation mechanism of micro-nano secondary phase in solid-liquid doped TZM alloy[J].Materials Characterization,2022,186:111800.
• [44] Majumdar S,Sharma I G,Raveendra S,et al.A study on preparation of Mo-0.6Ti-0.2Zr-0.02C alloy by mechanical alloying and hot isostatic pressing,and its characterization[J].Materials Chemistry and Physics,2009,113(2/3):562-566.
• [45] ■elko L,Tkachenko S,Casas-Luna M,et al.High-energy ball milling and spark plasma sintering of molybdenum-lanthanum oxide (Mo-La2O3) and molybdenum-lanthanum zirconate (Mo-La2Zr2O7) composite powders[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2022,102:105717.
• [46] Groza J R.5-Nanocrystalline Powder Consolidation Methods[M].Nanostructured Materials (Second Edition).Norwich,NY:William Andrew Publishing,2007:173-233.
• [47] Danisman C B,Yavas B,Yucel O,et al.Processing and characterization of spark plasma sintered TZM alloy[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2016,685:860-868.
• [48] Que Z,Wei Z,Li X,et al.Pressureless two-step sintering of ultrafine-grained refractory metals:Tungsten-rhenium and molybdenum[J].Journal of Materials Science & Technology,2022,126:203-214.
• [49] Li X,Zhang L,Dong Y,et al.Pressureless two-step sintering of ultrafine-grained tungsten[J].Acta Materialia,2020,186:116-123.
• [50] Dong Z,Chen S,Liu S,et al.Low-temperature accelerated sintering of high-performance oxide dispersion strengthened ultrafine grained Mo alloy[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2022,903:163982.
• [51] Xu L,Sun T,Zhou Y,et al.Evaluating compressive property and hot deformation behavior of molybdenum alloy reinforced by nanoscale zirconia particles[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2021,860:158289.
• [52] Cheng P M,Li S L,Zhang G J,et al.Ductilizing Mo-La2O3 alloys with ZrB2 addition[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2014,619:345-353.
• [53] Wang K S,Tan J F,Hu P,et al.La2O3 effects on TZM alloy recovery,recrystallization and mechanical properties[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2015,636:415-420.
• [54] Zhou Y C,Gao Y M,Wei S Z,et al.Preparation and properties of high-strength molybdenum alloy sheets doped with La2O3 particles[J].Rare Metals,2016,37(12):1046-1054.
• [55] Cui C,Gao Y,Wei S,et al.Microstructure and high temperature deformation behavior of the Mo-ZrO2 alloys[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2017,716:321-329.
• [56] Chao P C,Xiang W Z,Shu L L,et al.Effect of nano-sized ZrO2 on the recrystallization of Mo alloy[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2018,752:308-316.
• [57] Yao L,Gao Y,Li Y,et al.Microstructure,mechanical properties,and strengthening mechanisms of nanostructural Y-Zr-O oxide dispersion-strengthened (ODS) Mo alloys[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2022,921:166155.
• [58] Jiang D,Dong Z,Du Z,et al.Effect mechanism of oxide doping on the microstructure and mechanical properties of Mo-Y2O3 alloys[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2022,831:142344.
• [59] Hu B L,Han J Y,Ge S W,et al.Secondary phases strengthening-toughening effects in the Mo-TiC-La2O3 alloys[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2022,831:142271.
• [60] Zhang Z,Chen D.Consideration of orowan strengthening effect in particulate-reinforced metal matrix nanocomposites:A model for predicting their yield strength[J].Scripta Materialia,2006,54(7):1321-1326.
• [61] Zhang G J,Liu G,Sun Y J,et al.Microstructure and strengthening mechanisms of molybdenum alloy wires doped with lanthanum oxide particles[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2009,27(1):173-176.
• [62] Yao L,Gao Y,Huang Y,et al.Fabrication of Mo-Y2O3 alloys using hydrothermal synthesis and spark plasma sintering[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2021,98:105558.
• [63] Xu L,Li N,Song W,et al.Achieving an unprecedented strength-ductility balance of molybdenum alloy by homogeneously distributing yttrium-cerium oxide[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2022,897:163110.
• [64] Cui C,Zhu X,Liu S,et al.Effect of nano-sized ZrO2 on high temperature performance of Mo-ZrO2 alloy[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2018,768:81-87.
• [65] 王宾，周玉成，徐流杰，等.氧化物颗粒增强钼合金研究进展[J].特种铸造及有色合金，2022,42(9):1102-1109.WANG Bin,ZHOU Yu-cheng,XU Liu-jie,et al.Research progress in oxide particle reinforces molybdenum alloys[J].Special-cast and Non-ferrous Alloys,2022,42(9):1102-1109.
• [66] 王承阳，常洋，张林海，等.氧化锆含量对钼合金组织和性能的影响[J].粉末冶金技术，2021,39(5):429-433.WANG Cheng-yang,CHANG Yang,ZHANG Lin-hai,et al.Effect of ZrO2 content on microstructure and properties of molybdenum alloys[J].Powder Metallurgy Technology,2021,39(5):429-433.
• [67] Le Flem M,Allemand A,Urvoy S,et al.Microstructure and thermal conductivity of Mo-TiC cermets processed by hot isostatic pressing[J].Journal of Nuclear Materials,2008,380(1/3):85-92.
• [68] Takida T,Mabuchi M,Nakamura M,et al.Mechanical properties of a ZrC-dispersed Mo alloy processed by mechanical alloying and spark plasma sintering[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2000,276(1):269-272.
• [69] 董帝，康聚磊，熊宁，等.HfC含量对钼钛锆合金显微组织和力学性能的影响[J].粉末冶金技术，2021,39(3):239-244.DONG Di,KANG Ju-lei,XIONG Ning,et al.Effects of HfC content on microstructure and mechanical properties of titanium zirconium molybdenum alloys[J].Powder Metallurgy Technology,2021,39(3):239-244.
• [70] Liu X S,Liu M,Zhao X M,et al.Investigations on microstructure and mechanical properties of HfC particle-reinforced W Mo composites[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2021,100:105634.
• [71] Hu P,Yang F,Wang K S,et al.Preparation and ductile-to-brittle transition temperature of the La-TZM alloy plates[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2015,52:131-136.
• [72] Hu P,Li H,Zuo Y G,et al.Investigation of microstructure and tensile properties of as-processed TZM alloy at elevated temperature[J].Materials Characterization,2021,173:110933.
• [73] Hu P,Zhou Y,Chang T,et al.Investigation on compression behavior of TZM and La2O3 doped tzm alloys at high temperature[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2017,687:276-280.
• [74] Zhou Y,Wei S,Xu L,et al.Research on high-temperature properties of the molybdenum sheet doped with 1.0 wt%Al2O3 particles[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2018,769:340-346.
• [75] Gan J,Gong Q,Jiang Y,et al.Microstructure and high-temperature mechanical properties of second-phase enhanced Mo-La2O3-ZrC alloys post-treated by cross rolling[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2019,796:167-175.
• [76] Hu B L,Wang K S,Hu P,et al.Fracture behavior of the La-doped molybdenum-titanium-zirconium alloy[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2019,759:167-171.
• [77] Hu B L,Wang K S,Hu P,et al.Effect of secondary phases on the strength and elongation of a novel Mo-TiC-ZrC-C alloy[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2020,92:105336.
• [78] Jing K,Cheng X,Liu R,et al.Enhanced mechanical properties and thermal stability of hot-rolled Mo-0.5%ZrC alloy[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2022,854:143803.
• [79] Hiraoka Y,Okada M,Watanabe R.Effect of aging after carbon doping on the ductility of molybdenum[J].Journal of the Less Common Metals,1980,75(1):31-42.
• [80] Yavas B,Goller G.Investigation the effect of B4C addition on properties of TZM alloy prepared by spark plasma sintering[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2016,58:182-188.
• [81] Gottstein G,Shvindlerman L S.Theory of grain boundary motion in the presence of mobile particles[J].Acta Metallurgica et Materialia,1993,41(11):3267-3275.
• [82] Fleck N A,Muller G M,Ashby M F,et al.Strain gradient plasticity:Theory and experiment[J].Acta Metallurgica et Materialia,1994,42(2):475-487.
• [83] Mrotzek T,Martin U,Hoffmann A.High temperature deformation behavior of the molybdenum alloy TZM[J].Journal of Physics:Conference Series,2010,240:012079.
• [84] Li Y,Zhao Y H,Ortalan V,et al.Investigation of aluminum-based nanocomposites with ultra-high strength[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2009,527(1):305-316.
• [85] Sanaty-Zadeh A.Comparison between current models for the strength of particulate-reinforced metal matrix nanocomposites with emphasis on consideration of Hall-Petch effect[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2012,531:112-118.
• [86] Wang N,Ji Y,Wang Y,et al.Two modes of grain boundary pinning by coherent precipitates[J].Acta Materialia,2017,135:226-232.
• [87] Jiang S,Wang H,Wu Y,et al.Ultrastrong steel via minimal lattice misfit and high-density nanoprecipitation[J].Nature,2017,544(7651):460-464.
• [88] Dong Z,Ma Z,Yu L,et al.Achieving high strength and ductility in ODS-W alloy by employing oxide@W core-shell nanopowder as precursor[J].Nature Communications,2021,12(1):5052.
• [89] Hu W,Du Z,Dong Z,et al.The synthesis of TiC dispersed strengthened Mo alloy by freeze-drying technology and subsequent low temperature sintering[J].Scripta Materialia,2021,198:113831.
• [90] Wu S H,Hou Z Q,Zhang J Y,et al.Understanding the strength softening of Zr/Mo and Zr/Ti nanostructured multilayers[J].Scripta Materialia,2019,172:61-65.
• [91] Tuzemen C,Yavas B,Akin I,et al.Production and characterization of TZM based TiC or ZrC reinforced composites prepared by spark plasma sintering (SPS)[J].Journal of Alloys and Compounds,2019,781:433-439.
• [92] Raabe D,Herbig M,Sandl?bes S,et al.Grain boundary segregation engineering in metallic alloys:A pathway to the design of interfaces[J].Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science,2014,18(4):253-261.
• [93] Zhang T,Deng H W,Xie Z M,et al.Recent progresses on designing and manufacturing of bulk refractory alloys with high performances based on controlling interfaces[J].Journal of Materials Science & Technology,2020,52:29-62.
• [94] Leitner K,Felfer P J,Holec D,et al.On grain boundary segregation in molybdenum materials[J].Materials & Design,2017,135:204-212.
• [95] Brosse J B,Fillit R,Biscondi M.Intrinsic intergranular brittleness of molybdenum[J].Scripta Metallurgica,1981,15(6):619-623.
• [96] Mueller A J,Bianco R,Buckman R W.Evaluation of oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) molybdenum and molybdenum-rhenium alloys[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2000,18(4):205-211.
• [97] Xing H,Hu P,Han J,et al.Effects of oxygen on microstructure and evolution mechanism of body-centred-cubic molybdenum[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2022,103:105747.
• [98] Saage H,Krüger M,Sturm D,et al.Ductilization of Mo-Si solid solutions manufactured by powder metallurgy[J].Acta Materialia,2009,57(13):3895-3901.
• [99] Kurishita H,Asayama M,Tokunaga O,et al.Effect of TiC addition on the intergranular brittleness in molybdenum[J].Materials Transactions,JIM,1989,30(12):1009-1015.
• [100] Miller M K,Bryhan A J.Effect of Zr,B and C additions on the ductility of molybdenum[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2002,327(1):80-83.
• [101] Miller M K,Kenik E A,Mousa M S,et al.Improvement in the ductility of molybdenum alloys due to grain boundary segregation[J].Scripta Materialia,2002,46(4):299-303.
• [102] Hu W,Ma Z,Qian Z,et al.Influence of minor Ti additive on the microstructure and mechanical properties of Mo based alloys[J].International Journal of Refractory Metals and Hard Materials,2021,99:105599.
• [103] Zeng L F,Gao R,Fang Q F,et al.High strength and thermal stability of bulk Cu/Ta nanolamellar multilayers fabricated by cross accumulative roll bonding[J].Acta Materialia,2016,110:341-351.
• [104] Cheng P M,Zhang G J,Zhang J Y,et al.Coupling effect of intergranular and intragranular particles on ductile fracture of Mo-La2O3 alloys[J].Materials Science and Engineering A,2015,640:320-329.
• [105] Hu B L,Ge S W,Han J Y,et al.ZrTiO4 secondary phase effects on ductility and toughness of molybdenum alloys[J].Materials Lett

文章评论(Comment)：